I was reading the good piece about trying to get reasonable numbers on software product revenue. I can empathize with the challenge, because I was involved for many years (and even led efforts) in trying to guesstimate our competitors’ revenues by product, industry, and geography. I did this as an executive at MSC, Fluent, Engineous, Blue Ridge Numerics, and CD-adapco. I also did similar research as a consultant to CIMdata a few years ago and on my own in and around those other efforts. So I was struck by the statement below:
“We can then triangulate by product (easy to do, as public companies publish their results)”
I know from my own efforts (and being a corporate officer at a public company, MSC, from 1990-97) that public companies usually don’t publish their results by product line/name, only overall revenue by quarter and sometimes by geography and major business division. As Monica Schnitger wrote on February 9, 2016:
“When Dassault Systemes reports results, there’s a blizzard of information to wade through, all carefully orchestrated to lead the reader to the desired conclusion: that DS is a healthy, growing business with activities on many fronts contributing to long-term success. We get a lot of useful information, but many questions remain unanswered such as how are SIMULIA and DELMIA doing?”
So I wonder if the “easy to do” is Peter Thorne's statement or Ralph's interpretation? Either way, it’s questionable. However, my comments here are not meant to distract in any way from the generally high-quality efforts of Cambashi and upFront.eZine.
Compared to some market research charlatans (we’ve all seen their ads or postings on LinkedIn) who claim without hesitation that the FEA market in [fictional] Lower Slobovia will grow 10.283% between 2017 and 2020 and we should order their $1,500 report for all the details, your work is excellent.
I recall an anecdote from when a consulting firm paid a Chinese market research supplier to provide a report on the PLM market in China. In that report, there happened to be data on CD-adapco’s revenue in China. Since I was with CD-adapco as vice president until Jan. 1, 2011, I was amazed that the Chinese PLM report had CD-adapco China revenue numbers at a level of detail that even we at CD-adapco didn’t have!. - Dennis Nagy BeyondCAE
Peter Thorne of Cambashi replies: Dennis is correct, I said 'easy', but I was exaggerating, as it’s not easy and some of my Cambashi colleagues have also pointed this out to me! However, it is easier than some of the other drill downs and Sudoku-like constrain-and-converge steps.
One thing that helps is that we have a model for every major supplier, and each model has absorbed snippets provided by the supplier over the years. This doesn't mean a supplier’s five-year-old statement at a presentation in Singapore of A&D as a share of business in APAC [Asia-Pacific] is some kind of fixed point, but that statement will have influenced our model, and by adding these snippets in, it does mean we’ve got continually evolving supplier models into which we expect to fit this year’s figures.”
- - -
There's nothing easy about creating market numbers. Even if companies report data by product, geo [geoggraphy], seats, and units, they're often self-inconsistent over time and there's certainly inconsistency from vendor to vendor. Whenever a company releases this type of data, it needs to be viewed as marketing:
- What message are they trying to get across?
- Does a number of units include commercial, educational, both?
- What's in a product category and how are bundles handled?
This type of data should be suspect, because there are no clear definitions. What Cambashi brings (and what I tried to do at Daratech) is a set of definitions that don't change across vendors or time. It's very hard to do, and I appreciate the deep sanity-checking Cambashi does. It's the only way to even approximate something meaningful.
I wrote that paragraph [referenced by Mr Nagy] about Dassault Systemes after one of their earnings releases. It's frustrating when a vendor creates a bucket of random things simply to show growth. Dassault's "Other" category includes BIOVIA, CST, DELMIA, SIMULIA, Quintiq, and its other smaller brands. It's not clear which products grew during the period, or by how much.
Of course, Dassault isn't alone in this; others also define categories to create their desired perception. It's a trend that's not merely annoying to industry analysts, but dangerous for investors because they don't really know what they're buying. Yes, there may be overall growth but it's important to know what's driving the growth to assess how likely it is to continue. Investors are always buying future performance [which determines the current stock price]. -Monica Schnitger, principal analyst Schnitger Corp.
- - -
Interesting reading how Cambashi does what they do: gathering data, triangulating, adjusting as they learn about numbers that don’t appear to match. Cambashi is very, very good at what they do. -Jim Quanci Autodesk |
|
And Now the Rest of the News...
|
|
Some of the most recent posts on my WorldCAD Access blog:
- - -
IntelliCAD Technology Consortium quickens the pace of releases, with IntelliCAD v8.4 out just four months after v8.3. New in IntelliCAD v8.4 are the following functions: multileaders, quick leaders, break lines, select similar, get selection, explode text, explode attributes, more MText formatting options, auto numbering, and drawing properties. Drag'n drop is now possible in the Customize dialog box. And they added support for IFC, and improved handling of DGN files. http://www.intellicad.org
Aleksey Abramovsky describes how to use the Teigha Architecture APIs to draw a house in a CAD system that mimics AutoCAD for Architecture. As well, he lists the benefits to using the ODA's Teigha over Autodesk's ObjectARX. https://www.toptal.com/designers/css/dwgs-teigha-architecture
(You have to be a member of ITC and ODA respectively to take advantage of IntelliCAD and Teigha. Members then decide whether to integrate the new functions into their software sold to end users.)
Siemens PLM Software launches a new Automotive Solution, sounding a lot like PTC: "unites ALM with PLM" to combine embeddedhttps://www.plm.automation.siemens.com/en/automotive-transportation/automotive-software-development/index.cfm software and physical systems. (ALM is Application Lifecycle Management.) But then sounding a lot like Dassault, Siemens also says that in the coming months it will launch a series of solutions aimed at a wide variety of industries. https://www.plm.automation.siemens.com/en/automotive-transportation/automotive-software-development/index.cfm
Mapping company Bluesky has first map of heights for 41,083,111 buildings in all of England, Wales, Scotland. http://www.bluesky-world.com
Cenit of Germany acquires majority ownership of Keonys of France to become the largest Dassault VAR. But wait, there's more... Cenit AG also acquires majority interest in SynOpt GmbH, based in Leinfelden-Echterdingen and its simulation solutions for SIMULIA.
IronCAD updates Multiphysics (for stress, thermal, electrostatic and fluid analysis) with Extended Markup Language Data (XMD). http://www.ironcad.com/press/ironcad-announces-multiphysics-analysis-update-ironcad-2017-product-update-1/
Google's new Blocks program makes 3D parts for VR [virtual reality]. Export as OBJ files to AR [augmented reality], VR, Web pages, or as animated GIF files. https://www.blog.google/products/google-vr/blocks-easily-create-3d-objects-vr . In other VR news, IDC says sales in first half of 2017 were...
- Facebook Rift: 520,000 units
- HTC Vive: 770,000
- Sony PlayStation VR: 1.6 million
Meanwhile, in the world of IoT [Internet of Things], Intel is axing 140 staffers as it scales back its IoT operations after canceling Galileo, Joule and Edison modules. It seems that all Intel is successful at is making CPUs and only 8086-compatible CPUs.
Of all the problems that CAD creates, multi-generation data access is the most interesting one of all, as it is dead-serious. "Aerospace & defense no longer tolerates the escalating cost and risk of data loss associated with a PLM technology refresh," says James Roche. He'll be the speaker in a data obsolescence webinar hosted by CIMdata on August 10 at 11:00am EDT. Register at http://www.cimdata.com/en/education/educational-webinars/webinar-managing-plm-solution-and-data-obsolescence
- - -
For late-breaking CAD news, follow upFront.eZine on Twiter at @upfrontezine. |
|
Re: Big Data
I just said to someone the other day that we're living in times when people are so disconnected from reality that fantasy rules! But then, who's going to farm, invent, and fix things?
The editor replies: My wife's best friend married a farmer in Alberta, who with just his sons and sons-in-law does grain farming on nearly a thousand acres, including hundreds leased from retired farmers. I am astounded at what he does -- and puts up with. |
|
Thank you to readers who donate towards the operation of upFront.eZine:
- 3D PDF Consortium (small-company donation)
- Cristiano Sacchi and Franco Folini of NOVEDGE (USA): "Keep up the good work!"
- Andrew English of Civil Survey Solution (Australia, small-company donation): "We appreciate your independent reporting on the CAD industry."
Should you wish to support upFront.eZine through PayPal, then the suggested amounts are like these:
Should Paypal.me not operate in your country, then please use www.paypal.comand the account of [email protected].
Or mail a cheque (US$ or CDN$ only, please) to upFront.eZine Publishing, Ltd., 34486 Donlyn Avenue, Abbotsford BC, V2S 4W7, Canada. |
|
"The license model change for Autodesk and PTC led to down years for both, which pulled the overall market down." - @CIMdataPLMNews |
|
|
|
Comments