July 20, 2004
Issue #395

< Previous  Issue  Next >

 



T H E   B U S I N E S S   O F   C A D

- - -

C O N T E N T S

- - -

Vendor Support Survey, Par Deux
[results continue to be unpretty.]

Joe Dunne Comes to Visit
[chats up SolidWorks 2005.]

UGS Press Event
[presses the limit of the press's ability to absorb press releases.]

Below the Radar
and our other regular columns.


Write
the Editor

- - -

Donate
to upFront.eZine

- - -

Look for additional, nearly-daily CAD commentary at our Weblog:
WorldCAD Access.


  (ADVERTISMENT)

 

Updated and Expanded for AutoCAD 2004!

Tailoring AutoCAD 2004 is the first book for AutoCAD 2004. Download as a 204-page e-book in PDF format (US$24.95) or on CD ($29.95). Covers all areas of customization, from changing the user interface to writing toolbar macros and LISP routines.

Click here to sample preview pages and place your order.


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  

  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Vendor Support Survey, Par Deux

We've been testing how well CAD vendors respond to pre-sales enquires from potential customers. In this second round, we again sent a fairly technical question (involving 3D-to-2D dimensioning) to ten vendors, from a Hotmail email account.

We contacted the MCAD vendors by looking on their Web site for an email address or a Web form, which we then filled out. We kept track of the date of contact and when the firms responded -- if at all.

The following firms were contacted:

Alibre
Ashlar (Vellum Solids)
Autodesk (Inventor)
IMSI (TurboCAD)
Kubotek (KEYcreator)
Think3
UGS (NX)
UniCAD
Varimetrix
Varkon

We heard back from these firms:

  • Ashlar - one day later.
  • Alibre - one day later.
  • Varkon - posted our request to their user forum.

We plan a test of AEC CAD firms at some point in the future.

 


Joe Dunne Comes to Visit

SolidWorks 2005 is now available, and so Joe Dunne flew to the West Coast to show us the new release. Many of the improvements can be segregated into three categories:

  1. Machine design -- the largest share of the SolidWorks market.
  2. Mold making -- includes consumer design.
  3. AutoCAD compatibility.

For the user interface, new aspects are the Task Pane, Design Library, File Explorer, and Design Binder.

In the area of design, there is the Indent and Flex features, MoldflowXpress, dynamic lighting, curves on surface, enhanced weldments, curvature continuous loft, and more.

For bringing together parts, there are enhanced assembly explode and interference detection. Also, the note editor has been enhanced, there is a new DrawCompare, multi-user tools, and more.

- - -

For the AutoCAD user switching to SolidWorks, there's the new DWGEditor (based on Cadopia's flavor of IntelliCAD 4), auto dimensioning, enhanced sketch trims, enhanced spline tools, and new quick snaps.

When it comes to the AutoCAD-compatible DWGEditor, SolidWorks is quick to emphasis that it is not a replacement for AutoCAD. "If half your shop is AutoCAD and half SolidWorks, we're not saying replace the AutoCAD half with the DWGEditor," explains Mr Dunne. Hence, it is called "DWGEditor" -- and not DWGcreator.

The DWGEditor is meant for reading existing drawings saved in .dwg format, and then being able to edit them, if necessary, before importing them into SolidWorks. In addition, SolidWorks 2005 automatically creates associative part files and drawing files from Autodesk Mechanical Desktop files.

www.solidworks.com


UGS Press Event

The "new" CAD company, UGS, held an event for the media last week in New York City. I'd loved to have gone, but UGS was springing only for hotel, not the air fare. What with my son's Grade 12 graduation, the in-law's 50th wedding anniversary, and me fracturing my fibula, I'd forgotten about the event until pr guy John Day starting sending email after email loaded with press releases.

I've reproduced the 15 headlines below, and you can take from them what you will:

  • UGS Announces Availability of New Teamcenter Multi-CAD Engineering Collaboration Solution. Teamcenter supports engineering process and data management for CAD authoring applications including AutoCAD, CATIA, NX, Pro/Engineer, Solid Edge, and SolidWorks.
  • UGS Introduces NX Managed Development Environment. NX Managed Development Environment will set new standard for digital product development process by digitally connecting products, processes and people; provides support for lean design and design for Six Sigma.
  • UGS Announces Family of Products and Enhancements Enabling Interoperability with CATIA Product Design Software V5. Available directly from UGS and powered by PLM XML, new offerings and capabilities enable high performance data exchange and interoperability between CATIA product design software V5 and UGS’ NX, Teamcenter, and E-factory products.
  • DaimlerChrysler Selects NX Nastran from UGS. Saab AB selects UGS’ market-leading Teamcenter solution to optimize aircraft program efficiency. Rolls-Royce Selects UGS for Trent 1000 and TP400 New Engine Projects.
  • Hyundai Heavy Industries Switchgear Operations Selects UGS as its PLM System Provider. Raytheon Space and Airborne Systems Expands Commitment to NX Digital Simulation Offerings from UGS.
  • UGS Launches New Version of E-factory Jack, its Human Simulation and Ergonomics Analysis Software. Jack V4.1 simplifies creation of digital human animations.
  • UGS Launches New Versions of E-factory plant layout and material handling solutions. Factory CAD and Factory Flow Versions 9.0 improve accuracy of factory designs and speed up optimization of material flow.
  • DaimlerChrysler, Renault, Visteon and Caterpillar Become Latest Corporate Members of JT Open Initiative. Theorem and Opticore also sign on as JT Open vendor members.
  • UGS and Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) Form Strategic Partnership to Optimize and Expand Delivery of Comprehensive Product Lifecycle Management Solutions.
  • UGS Re-brands Industry-leading Software Grant Program as GO PLM; Commercial Value of Program Grants in 2003 Exceeded US$2 Billion.
  • UGS Accelerates Opportunities for Global University Students and Staff Through US$119 Million Software Grant.

"One more," Mr Day writes, "This should be it for today. Whew!"

  • UGS Announces Availability of New Teamcenter Sourcing Capabilities. New functionality, "Powered by eBreviate," aggressively expands UGS' PLM presence in sourcing and SRM, bolstered by formalized agreement with A.T. Kearney. [Should that be UGS' or UGS's?]

- - -

And, Mike Paludan has a new job at UGS Solid Edge as marketing director for the Americas sales zone. Taking his place at Solid Edge global public relations is Susan Cinadr <Susan.Cinadr @ ugs.com>.


Below the Radar

A summary of CAD industry news you may not have read elsewhere, or that we found interesting:

Alibre Design 8.0, due out late this summer, adds free-form modeling for 3D sketches and surfaces. Version 8 also imports surfaces for slicing, extruding, and thickening. www.alibre.com  

L PRIZE is a software developer contest to write the next generation of freeware LEGO CAD tools. www.lprize.com

Spicer releases DocuJet 3.0 for generating raster images from any Windows application, eliminating the need to print and then scan-to-file. Download free eval copy from www.spicer.com

Informative Graphics says that its free ModelPress Reader now supports IronCAD’s native 3D file format, and is distributed with the new IronCAD v7. www.infograph.com

Cadro's HatchKit v2.3 is a visual editor for hatch pattern definition (PAT) files used by AutoCAD, Revit, IntelliCAD, and others. www.cadro.com.au/hatchkit/

Cimmetry Systems reports that its AutoVue 18 (due out this month) includes digital mockup, where you simulate models and assemblies on-the-fly, and project real-world manufacturability. The update also verifies EDA designs for manufacturability, cross-probes 3D PCBs, and more. www.cimmetry.com

CADAddOn.com has AutoXlsTable v2.51 for AutoCAD 2000 and higher. It does things that AutoCAD 2005's new Table command cannot, such as import Excel files and perform calculations. The company notes that the average upgrade fee for AutoCAD 2005 is US$700, but that their product is $168. www.cadaddon.com

DRCAUTO Software completes LT Toolkit Max (US$450) for AutoCAD LT 2005, providing it the ability to run AutoLISP, ObjectARX, ObjectDBX, and !SlingShot Max 2005. estore.drcauto.com/lttoolkitmax.htm

Dassault Systèmes has a SmartTeam-based PLM module for electronics manufacturers, called "Collaborative Systems Engineering for Electronics." www.3ds.com

Empresa Solutions introduces ChangeWorks for full control over creation, revision, review, and release of SolidWorks designs. www.empresasolutions.com

BricsCad V5 for Linux will be beta-released later this month, with a commercial version ready at the end of September. The software is the Windows version tweaked to run on Linux under the WINE emulator. www.bricscad.com

And MultiCIM Technologies announces PRO Menu (US$99) for AutoCAD 2005 and AutoCAD LT 2005. Download a trial version from www.multicim.com/pmenu.html  . The company also offers PRO Key (US$39), a new keyboard macro recorder/player for AutoCAD and AutoCAD LT.


Seminars & Conference

The first conference for application developers interested in IntelliCAD is Sept 16-17 in Denver CO USA. [I'll be speaking at this event.] www.intellicad.org/WorldMeeting2004/

SolidWorks World 2005 takes place at Disney Coronado Springs Resort Jan 30 - Feb 2, 2005 in Orlando FL USA. www.solidworks.com/pages/SWWorld05/main.html


People/Companies on the Move

RAND Worldwide acquired RGB Technologies, providing Rand with access to the northeastern region of France and its automotive customer sector.

Former Visio founders  Jeremy Jaech and Ted Johnson landed US$4.75 million in venture financing for their latest company, The Graw Group -- "a consumer Web-service company that is helping to coordinate family members and the communities to which they belong."

Nautical Data International commenced a $68-million copyright infringement action against C-Map USA and Navionics over Canadian nautical charts. NDI claims that the two pirated the data, and then sold digital nautical charts for use with their proprietary hardware and software. The Canadian Hydrographic Service gave NDI the exclusive right to convert paper charts into digital format for resale.


WorthWhile Web

www.sundog.clara.co.uk/atoptics/phenom.htm
Atmospheric Optics
Light playing on water drops, dust or ice crystals in the atmosphere produces a host of visual spectacles -- rainbows, halos, glories, coronas.
        - Thanks to Don Beaton

www.stargroup.com/ResidentialInspections.htm?hnt/rt003.html~main
Some really good home building faux pas. See the "How Not To" section.
     
   - Thanks to Chris Lockhart


Letters to the Editor

Re: How Many 3D Users?

        "Good work on the story. The June 24 press release issued by Wohlers Associates in cooperation with Joe Greco reported that an estimated 4.96 million MCAD seats were installed worldwide through the end of 2003. As you pointed out in your June 13 article, this total includes both commercial and educational seats.

"Individual estimates were provided by the vendor companies named in your article, although seats are counted differently from one vendor to the next. Also, it's important to understand that the total does not necessarily reflect what is currently being used. Some of these seats may be (and probably are) inactive.

"The commercial (only) installations represent an estimated 1.194 million of the nearly 5 million seats, according to our study. This compares to 1.172 million commercial 3D seats that Cambashi had estimated."
        - Terry Wohlers
        Wohlers Associates

 

"There is a debate going on at the moment in one of the Sydney architectural community's on-line discussion groups re: CAD 2D or 3D or ?"
        - Robert Israel
        Sydney AutoCAD User Group

 

"2D drafting has been around since before the Greeks and Egyptians first carved their layouts into the stone slabs they were constructing with and will not be going anywhere soon. I do not see its demise in my lifetime.

"3D is an excellent tool for explaining how something works, but it will not be replacing 2D in construction documents any time soon."
        - Brian Grishaber
        Toronto

The editor replies: "3D looks like the finished object, but hides information; 2D shows more data concerning the object to be built."

 

"I heard the story about an old, experienced carpenter who was told of the brave new paperless future in which projects would be built from plans on laptops, which were wirelessly updated daily from the home office to reflect changes and updates, etc.  

"'Well, with the old roll plans, when I drop 'em off the roof, they still work.'  

"Sort of typifies to me the difference between function and paradigm shift."
        - Walt Cheever

 

"You reminded me of the first CAD program I used, down under here in Sydney, Australia. The package was from the United Kingdom, and was called MLDraft.

"As far as I know, it was a minicomputer package, ported to the IBM PC. It ran on 8086s and above, DOS based, and developed into a fully parameterized version, with a programming interface developed by some users into some really powerful tools.

"A local (Sydney) steel fabrication firm developed a package to automatically detail shop drawings, based on current Australian standards. One English company developed a package that only required a few inputs, to then calculate and draw a complete portal frame type building -- plans, elevations, sections and details automatically.

 

"MLDraft was competing with some much more rudimentary packages, and decided to go 3D. Unfortunately, an emerging giant -- AutoCAD -- appeared. Marketing overwhelmed them as I recall. Anyone have any comments?"
        - Robert Israel
        Australia

 

"In response to your reader's letter, Bentley Institute offers a comprehensive 3-day course titled 'Everything 3D'. This course covers 3D topics from how to navigate in 3D and using AccuDraw in 3D to advanced 3D surface manipulation and, new to MicroStation, Feature modeling. As part of this course, the student is equipped with a thoroughly updated course guide (22 chapters, 406 pages.) For more information on when and where these courses are being held, visit bentleyinstitute.bentley.com and click on 'Instructor-led Courses'."
        - Frank Conforti  
        Bentley Systems

- - -

"I find the information you post quite interesting, and I enjoy your editorial comments. Thanks for doing such a great job of winnowing out the chaff, and providing just the good kernels of news of the CAD world. Now if the hype writers and publicity crowd would do the same."
        - Steve Hudson
        Oak Hill Marine Design

 

"Keep up the good work."
        - Phil Kreiker
        Looking Glass Microproducts


Notable Quotable

"People in the industry have known that, but there seems to be great reluctance to speak about it openly."
        -  Felix Pilorusso, auto industry consultant describing the commercial failure of fuel cells for automobiles.
       
www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/storyllard0717

Return to www.upfrontezine.com.

Entire contents copyright ©2004 by upFront.eZine Publishing, Ltd. All rights reserved worldwide. Article reprint fee $500. All trademarks belong to their respective holders. "upFront.eZine," "Talking About CAD," and "On your desktop every Tuesday morning" are trademarks of upFront.eZinePublishing, Ltd. Letters to the editor may be reproduced in an edited form for clarity and brevity. Opinions expressed in letters are not necessarily shared by upFront.eZine Publishing, Ltd.

 D o n a t i o n s

This e-newsletter is shareware. You may read this free.

If you would like to support the author in his work, we suggest a donation of US$25.00 to PayPal in the account of grabowski @ telus.net.

Click here to make payment.

Make your donation via PayPal.

Reprint fee: US$500

.